Dog Whimpering: Why a Dog’s Whimper Affects Us

To pet parents, a whimpering dog sounds as sad as a crying baby. Here’s why

31 October 2023

Dog whimpering can have a handful of meanings, but it basically chalks up to one purpose: communication. Dogs whimper to communicate with each other and with humans. “A large majority of canine communication is through manipulation of the body,” says Renee Rhoades, an applied animal behaviourist and founder of R+Dogs, a virtual canine behaviour practice. Sometimes vocalisations, such as whimpering, serve as a more direct and urgent way for dogs to convey their needs.

The sound of a dog whimpering is both attention-grabbing and heart-wrenching, and that’s exactly the point. In short, researchers found that a whimpering dog sounds as sad as a crying baby to some pup parents, even suggesting that dogs have evolved effective distress signals due to their dependence on humans.

If your dog is whimpering for attention, they’re counting on you to hone in on their body language and other cues to figure out why. If you’ve considered all the reasons why your dog is whimpering and are still unsure of the cause, err on the side of caution and take your dog to the vet. They’ll rule out any medical problems.

Boxer dog sits in back of car with head in the front

How Do I Stop My Dog From Crying In the Car?

Is there anything more annoying than a dog who won’t stop whining? Here’s what to do about it

Why are pet owners affected by a dog’s whimpering?

Humans and dogs share a similar emotional reaction to high-pitched sounds, and it isn’t just a coincidence. Higher-frequency noises in humans and non-human species often indicate danger, so we’ve developed an innate reaction to respond as a protective mechanism.

What’s more is that research has shown that pet parents, in particular, are more attuned to distress sounds from their furry friends. A study involving over 500 young adults found that dog whines evoke a stronger negative response from pet parents compared to those without pets. We could assume this heightened sensitivity deepens the emotional connection between humans and their pets.

However, Rhoades points out that we can also become conditioned to associate whining or whimpering with negative behaviours. This can lead us to feel annoyed rather than empathetic when a dog whines or whimpers. “Please do not discount your dog’s whimpering and whining as negative or ‘bad’ behaviour and disregard it or try to punish it,” she counters.

Are humans more receptive to dog whines than cat meows?

That same study involving more than 500 young adults found that cat parents had a less significant response to cat meows than dog parents had to dog whining. Katherine Young, a collaborator on the study, suggests that dogs may have more effective distress signals due to their greater dependence on humans. After all, she considers cats to be semi-domesticated, requiring less general care than dogs.

The Cat’s Meow – What Does it All Mean?

How to decode your cat’s love language when one meow has many meanings

“This difference in animal dependence may explain why dog whines are rated as more negative than cat meows by all adults, including cat owners. Dogs may simply have more effective distress signals than cats,” she told Neuroscience News.

Why is my dog whimpering?

Dogs whimper to get attention, and they’re very good at it. But Rhoades warns that we shouldn’t shrug off our dogs’ whimpering. Instead, she says to practice patience and compassion, giving them the benefit of the doubt. Dogs have important stuff to say.

They need to use the bathroom

Other signs that your dog needs to go to the toilet include pacing and door monitoring. Remember that while every dog’s schedule can vary, a good rule of thumb is to let your dog out at least every six hours. Puppies need loo breaks every 1-3 hours, depending on their age.

They’re seeking affection or play

If your dog is extra vocal, it may be a sign they simply want more of your time. “In situations like this, I run through the list of options somewhat like a baby,” Rhoades says. “I think about what my dog has done during that day, and if I have been able to meet all of their needs.”

They’re asking for food or to have another treat

If you’re sticking to a regular feeding schedule – most vets recommend it – you shouldn’t need to feed your dog between meals. On top of the risk of weight gain, rewarding whimpering with food could encourage your pup to do it more often.

How to Teach Your Dog to ‘Talk’ at the Touch of a Button

Cognitive science professor Dr Federico Rossano on how Bunny, TikTok’s ‘talking’ dog, is sparking change in how we communicate with our pets

Fear, anxiety, or stress

“ Loud noises, new atmospheres, and car rides are common stressors in dogs,” says Dr Tara Hansen, a veterinarian at Chewy. Some dogs may hide, pant or refuse food when stressed, anxious or scared. Others become more vocal, such as whimpering or barking, restless or agitated.

Frustration or confusion

Dogs often whine when they are frustrated or confused. This can happen when they’re restrained, such as by a lead or fence, or when they are unsure about a situation or the intentions of another animal or person.

Excitement

Dogs whine when they are happy or excited, and you can usually tell by context and their body language. For instance, if your dog runs to you, is willing to put on their harness, and then runs to the door whining, they’re excited, says Rhoades.

Pain or discomfort

If you notice your dog whining, especially if there are other changes in behaviours such as restlessness, pacing or licking a particular area, take them to the vet to rule out any medical problems.

A health condition

Unfortunately, your dog may be whimpering due to a health problem. If your dog is whining excessively, it’s important to rule out any medical problems with your vet. Once you have done this, you can seek professional help from a trainer to address any behavioural issues that may be contributing to the whining.

“Any qualified ethical dog professional will encourage you to have your dog physically examined before doing any behaviour work, as this is the golden standard,” says Rhoades.

pet lover concept with mini dog on woman leg. sitting in room at home

What’s the Deal, Mouthy Puppies? Why Bite Inhibition Matters

How to teach your pup to play nice

Is it common for dogs to whimper?

It’s common for dogs to whimper when they are excited, hungry, frightened, confused, in pain or uncomfortable. It’s important to never ignore your dog’s whimpering, as it may be a sign of a problem or an unfulfilled need.

How do you calm a whimpering dog?

According to Rhoades, there is no one-size-fits-all solution to calming a whimpering dog. The best way to reduce whining is to ensure that you are meeting your dog’s needs, providing a routine and using positive reinforcement training. Hansen offers the following solutions for specific situations:

Attention-seeking whining: wait until your dog is calm before engaging with them, responding to attention-seeking whimpers only reinforces the behaviour. If all other needs seem to be met, try to find an enrichment activity to keep your dog occupied, such as puzzles, interactive games, exercise or sniff walks.
Stress-related whining: try to identify and modify or remove the stressor while comforting your dog. For example, if your dog whines when you leave for work in the morning, try leaving them with a Kong filled with peanut butter or other treats to keep them occupied. If your dog has persistent stress or anxious behaviours, especially if they seem generalised, they may need to be addressed by a veterinarian or behaviourist. The same is true for pups who repeatedly whine, cry or show other signs of distress when in kennels.
Excitement-related whining: some vocalising is normal dog behaviour and doesn’t need discouraging or remedied, and whimpering out of excitement is one example. However, if the excitement is undesirable, speak to your dog calmly and try to redirect their attention to something else using positive reinforcement techniques.
Pain-related whining: “Make a vet appointment right away. Dogs tend to be stoic and quiet when they are uncomfortable, so vocalisation due to pain is a sign that veterinary attention is needed promptly,” says Hansen.

If your dog keeps whimpering for no reason (Rhoades and Hansen say there is always a reason!), first, see your vet, then consider working with a certified dog trainer.

To Cry Is Human – and Apparently Canine

Time to whip out The Notebook for a doggy movie night

Frequently asked questions

Is it bad if my dog is whimpering?

Whimpering is a natural form of canine communication, so it’s not inherently bad. “Do not discount your dog's whimpering and whining as negative or ‘bad’ behaviour and disregard it or try to punish it,” says Rhoades. However, if your dog is whimpering excessively, it is important to assess the situation and determine whether the behaviour is normal or requires professional intervention.

When should I go to the vet if my dog is whimpering

If you can’t figure out why your dog is whimpering, take them to the vet. In fact, Rhoades says, behaviourists will typically recommend a veterinary checkup before working with a dog that is whimpering excessively. “If you see signs of illness like lack of appetite, lethargy, limping or intense licking at an area, discomfort might be a logical explanation,” Hansen says, and your dog should see their vet.

References:

Claudia Kawczynska

Claudia Kawczynska was co-founder and editor-in-chief of The Bark for 20 years. She also edited the best-selling anthology Dog Is My Co-Pilot.

Dog Whimpering: Why a Dog’s Whimper Affects Us

Share Article

How Do I Stop My Dog From Crying In the Car?

Why are pet owners affected by a dog’s whimpering?